The Government and Natural England have been formally found to be failing legal duties to protect wild birds, following an investigation by the independent Office for Environmental Protection (OEP).
In decision notices issued on 18 November 2026, the watchdog identified failures to comply with environmental law and warned that years of delay had left important habitats without sufficient protection.
The findings come as official figures show that 45% of 132 native breeding bird species have declined over five years. The OEP has given the authorities two months to respond before it considers further action.
Government and Natural England issued formal notices
The Office for Environmental Protection (OEP) has issued decision notices to Defra and Natural England after finding failures to comply with environmental law governing wild birds and their habitats. The statutory watchdog says longstanding delays have left significant sites without sufficient protection. These are regulatory findings, not court judgments.
Almost half of native breeding species declining
Official figures cited by the OEP show that 45% of 132 native breeding bird species declined over a five-year period. The watchdog says UK wild bird populations are at their lowest recorded level. Species experiencing declines include swifts, turtle doves, tree sparrows, wood warblers and bullfinches.
Why Special Protection Areas matter
Special Protection Areas (SPAs) are legally protected land and sea sites important for rare and vulnerable birds during breeding, migration and winter. The OEP says recommendations intended to improve the SPA network, some dating to 2001, remain unimplemented. The Severn Estuary and The Wash are examples of important sites; The Wash regularly supports more than 400,000 wintering waterbirds.
Watchdog warns of prolonged delays
Helen Venn, the OEP’s chief regulatory officer, warned that continuing delays had left important habitats without adequate protection and increased the work required to build a sufficient SPA network. The findings also bear on wider environmental commitments, including species-abundance targets and the ambition to protect 30% of land and seas for nature recovery by 2030.
Some progress acknowledged
The watchdog welcomed constructive engagement with Natural England and Defra, including work on future SPA designations and threatened-species recovery planning. Nevertheless, it concluded that further action is required to meet legal obligations within a reasonable timeframe.
RSPB demands urgent protection
The RSPB welcomed the findings and called for new or expanded protected areas and targeted measures for threatened species such as curlews, bitterns and hen harriers. Its recommendations are the conservation charity’s position, not an announced Government policy.
Northern Ireland also receives decision notice
In a parallel investigation, the OEP issued a decision notice to Northern Ireland’s Department of Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs (DAERA) over failures to protect wild birds. Minister Andrew Muir acknowledged longstanding shortcomings and said the department was working on habitat recovery and protected-area plans.
Two months to respond
Defra and Natural England have two months to respond to the decision notices. The OEP will consider their responses before deciding what happens next. It aims to resolve non-compliance through cooperation but can pursue further enforcement, including court proceedings where necessary. No court ruling has been made in this matter.
Investigation dates back to 2024
The OEP launched its investigation in March 2024 and issued information notices in June 2025 after identifying possible breaches. The November 2026 decision notices are a further formal step. Some underlying shortcomings predate the current Government, although current authorities must now respond to the watchdog’s findings.