Neutral

Immigration and Asylum Bill Clears House of Commons by 196-Vote Majority

MPs have approved the Immigration and Asylum Bill by 290 votes to 94. Proposed changes to removals, appeals and modern slavery procedures now face House of Lords scrutiny.

By Charlotte Mercer • Published 18 November 2026 at 16:00 • 3 min read
Share article X Facebook LinkedIn WhatsApp Email

The Government’s Immigration and Asylum Bill has cleared the House of Commons after MPs voted 290 to 94 in favour, a majority of 196. The vote took place on Tuesday 17 November 2026; the Home Office published its announcement on 18 November. The Bill now moves to the House of Lords and is not yet law.

Commons approves legislation

The Third Reading vote followed debate about asylum procedures, removals and settlement. Fourteen Labour MPs voted against the Bill. Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood said the legislation would speed decisions and close perceived loopholes; opponents raised concerns about safeguards and the effects on people already living in Britain.

Changes to removal notices

A Government amendment would permit Immigration Enforcement to remove certain people whose appeals to the proposed Independent Immigration Appeals Authority have failed without a further five-working-day notice period. The Home Office says officers would have a six-month window for removal before additional notice becomes necessary. This would apply after relevant appeal rights have been exhausted, not eliminate initial appeal rights.

New appeals authority

The Bill proposes an Independent Immigration Appeals Authority to handle appeals and facilitate faster decisions. The Government expects to recruit a chair by spring 2027. It also proposes a single definition of protection claims combining refugee status and humanitarian protection.

Modern slavery claims

Ministers propose statutory provisions addressing what they describe as bad-faith modern slavery claims. The Home Office reports that nearly 80% of National Referral Mechanism referrals last year involved people subject to immigration controls, including 4,526 referrals from detention. Those figures do not establish that the referrals were fraudulent. The final safeguards and legal tests remain subject to parliamentary scrutiny.

Human rights and settlement debate

The Bill also proposes clarifying the application of Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights in immigration decisions. Separately, the Government’s wider settlement reforms have prompted disagreement over plans to extend the standard qualifying period from five to ten years, with concessions proposed for some health and social care workers. The precise interaction of the Bill and immigration-rule changes must not be assumed to be settled.

Opposition and Labour criticism

Fourteen Labour MPs opposed the Bill at Third Reading, with concerns including settlement rights and the position of existing migrants. Shadow Home Secretary Chris Philp argued that the measures did not go far enough to secure removals. Other critics warned about the effect of proposed changes on families and vulnerable applicants.

Government claims on progress

The Home Office says small boat arrivals have fallen, returns have reached a decade-long high and costs to taxpayers have decreased by £1 billion. These are the Government’s claims about its wider record, not results of this Bill, which has yet to become law.

What happens next

The Bill must undergo House of Lords scrutiny and may be amended before returning to the Commons if necessary. It will require Royal Assent before becoming an Act, and individual provisions may have separate commencement dates. The confirmed milestone is Commons approval by 290 votes to 94, not implementation of the proposed reforms.

Have a different view?

Write a response.

Challenge the argument, add relevant evidence or explain how this issue affects people in practice. We welcome thoughtful, evidence-led contributions from across the political debate.

Write for Ayes To The Right
Know this MP?

Have first-hand knowledge or experience?

Have you worked with Chris Philp and Shabana Mahmood? Do you have direct experience of this issue, their work or their recent parliamentary record?

We are interested in informed perspectives, constructive criticism and accounts that help readers understand the subject more clearly.

Write an article about this topic

Related articles